From the 1950s through the 1970s, John Kenneth Galbraith stood out as one of the most widely read economists in the United States, captivating a broad audience with his eloquent writing style and sharp wit. His ability to articulate complex economic concepts with clever and sometimes provocative phrasing made his arguments both accessible and memorable, often highlighting the perceived follies of his intellectual adversaries. Galbraith’s career began to gain significant traction with his early work, establishing him as a prominent voice in economic discourse.
His first major publication, American Capitalism: The Concept of Countervailing Power, released in 1952, presented a groundbreaking analysis of the evolving structure of the American economy. In this seminal work, John Kenneth Galbraith argued that the ascendance of large corporations had fundamentally altered the economic landscape, rendering the traditional model of perfect competition largely obsolete. However, Galbraith offered a nuanced perspective, suggesting that this concentration of corporate power was counterbalanced by the rise of large labor unions. This “countervailing power,” he posited, served as a crucial mechanism to protect consumers and maintain equilibrium in the market by creating competing centers of influence.
John Kenneth Galbraith achieved even greater prominence with his 1958 book, The Affluent Society. This influential work explored the paradoxical contrast between the opulence of the private sector and the relative deprivation of the public sector in American society. This dichotomy resonated with many who shared Galbraith’s critical view of consumerism, drawing parallels to Thorstein Veblen’s critique of “conspicuous consumption.” However, Galbraith’s stance was more nuanced than a simple condemnation of consumer desires. He acknowledged that even consumer wants with “bizarre, frivolous, or even immoral origins” could still hold a justifiable place in the economy. His central argument was more deeply rooted in the idea of want creation. Galbraith contended that for individual wants to be genuinely urgent, they must originate from the individual themselves, not be artificially manufactured by the very industries that fulfill them. He argued, “One cannot defend production as satisfying wants if that production creates the wants,” a statement that challenged the conventional economic justification for unlimited production based on consumer demand.
This perspective sparked considerable debate, notably drawing a critical response from Friedrich Hayek. Hayek challenged Galbraith’s premise by pointing out that most human wants, beyond basic biological needs like food, shelter, and sex, are indeed learned and culturally influenced. He argued that aesthetic preferences and cultural pursuits, essential components of human achievement, are acquired tastes rather than innate desires. Hayek countered that dismissing a desire as unimportant merely because it is not innate would be to discount the entirety of human cultural development, fundamentally disagreeing with Galbraith’s emphasis on the manufactured nature of consumer wants.
John Kenneth Galbraith’s most comprehensive work, his magnum opus, The New Industrial State, was published in 1967. In this book, he further developed his thesis on the dominance of large corporations in the American economy. He asserted that mature corporations possess considerable control over market dynamics, influencing both the prices of their products and the costs of their inputs. Illustrating this point, Galbraith used General Motors as an example, arguing that as the producer of approximately half of all automobiles, the company’s design choices dictated prevailing automotive trends, rather than reflecting pre-existing consumer preferences. He wrote, “The proper shape of an automobile, for most people, will be what the automobile makers decree the current shape to be,” highlighting the power of corporations to shape consumer taste.
However, empirical evidence has not consistently supported Galbraith’s propositions regarding the unyielding power of corporations. Even industry giants are susceptible to market pressures and can face financial losses if they fail to meet consumer demand. The example of General Motors itself serves as a counterpoint. Despite being a prime example in Galbraith’s analysis, GM’s market share in the U.S. declined significantly from approximately 50% when The New Industrial State was published to less than half of that by 2005, demonstrating the impact of market forces and evolving consumer preferences.
Born in Canada, John Kenneth Galbraith immigrated to the United States in the 1930s. He earned his Ph.D. in agricultural economics from the University of California at Berkeley, marking the beginning of his distinguished academic and public service career. During World War II, Galbraith played a crucial role in economic policy as the head of the Price Section of the Office of Price Administration, becoming a key figure in wartime price controls. Unusually among economists, he advocated for the implementation of permanent price controls as a tool of economic management. In 1943, he transitioned to journalism, joining the editorial board of Fortune magazine. Following the war, Galbraith directed the U.S. Strategic Bombing Survey, which notably concluded that the saturation bombing of Germany had not been particularly effective in significantly hindering German war production. Returning to academia, he became a professor of economics at Harvard University in 1949, after a prior brief stint before the war, solidifying his position as a leading academic voice.
Galbraith’s influence extended beyond academia into the realm of politics and public policy. He served as an advisor to President John F. Kennedy, held the position of Kennedy’s ambassador to India, and presided over Americans for Democratic Action, reflecting his active engagement in political and social issues. His contributions to the field of economics were formally recognized when he served as president of the American Economic Association in 1972, underscoring his lasting impact and recognition within the economics profession.
Selected Works
-
American Capitalism. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
-
A Theory of Price Control. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
-
The Affluent Society. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
-
How to Get out of Viet Nam. New York: New American Library.
-
The New Industrial State. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
-
Life in Our Times. Boston: Houghton Mifflin
Alt texts for images:
First image alt text: John Kenneth Galbraith portrait. A black and white portrait of John Kenneth Galbraith, a prominent 20th-century economist known for his influential books on American capitalism and society.
Second image alt text: The Affluent Society book cover. The book cover of “The Affluent Society” by John Kenneth Galbraith, a landmark work analyzing the contradictions of wealth and poverty in modern economies.
