It’s genuinely difficult not to be captivated from the outset when watching “El Dorado.” This classic Western, anchored by stellar performances and a compelling narrative, showcases why it remains a beloved film decades after its release. Directed with expertise by Howard Hawks, and headlined by the iconic John Wayne, “El Dorado” delivers a masterclass in ensemble acting and classic Western storytelling.
At the heart of “El Dorado” is John Wayne, portraying a skilled gunfighter who rides into the tumultuous landscape to aid a sheriff grappling with his inner demons. This sheriff, played with remarkable depth by Robert Mitchum, is battling alcoholism while trying to maintain order in his town. Wayne’s character is supported by a memorable ensemble, including a youthful James Caan, wielding a distinctive scatter-gun, and Arthur Hunnicutt, embodying the seasoned wisdom of a grizzled Indian fighter deputy. Together, this quartet stands against the menacing presence of a ruthless landowner, portrayed by Ed Asner, and his hired gun, played by Christopher George, along with a posse of other gunslingers eager for confrontation. The conflict ignites as Wayne and his allies side with the MacDonalds, a family of landowners being aggressively pressured by Asner, setting the stage for a dramatic showdown in El Dorado.
“El Dorado” distinguishes itself with its sharp pacing and a script that allows each character to breathe and develop. The acting is, as expected from such a cast, exceptional. Even actors like James Caan and Ed Asner, who might seem unconventional choices for a Western, seamlessly integrate into the genre, delivering compelling and believable performances. John Wayne, as always, commands the screen. His mere presence is magnetic, and the subtle nuances he brings to his role are a joy to watch. It’s particularly enjoyable to hear Wayne’s distinctive drawl pronounce “Mississippi” when addressing Caan’s character, a small detail that adds to the film’s charm. Robert Mitchum, however, is given the more challenging role, portraying a sheriff wrestling with his alcoholism, a role reportedly coveted by Wayne himself. The film deftly handles the delicate balance of humor and pathos as the heroes grapple with the task of sobering up the very man entrusted to protect their town, who has unfortunately become its laughing stock. Arthur Hunnicutt, as the deputy, steals many scenes with his dry wit and proves to be invaluable when the stakes are raised. Adding to the film’s allure is Michele Carey, portraying a member of the MacDonald clan. While perhaps not as widely recognized as her co-stars, Carey leaves a lasting impression as a strikingly beautiful and resourceful woman determined to stand up against Asner’s tyranny.
Beyond the thrilling gunfights that are integral to the Western genre, “El Dorado” offers moments of genuine camaraderie and warmth between its stars. There’s a palpable sense of enjoyment as Wayne, Mitchum, and the rest of the cast share scenes, creating a dynamic that feels both authentic and engaging. The film also manages to inject fresh elements into familiar Western tropes. A shootout intertwined with the resonant ringing of church bells provides a unique and memorable cinematic moment, adding a layer of originality to the action sequences. Similarly, James Caan’s effective use of a shotgun to dispatch villains offers a refreshing change from the typical six-shooter duels, highlighting a less common weapon in classic Westerns. While a brief and arguably dated impersonation of a “Chinaman” by Caan might raise eyebrows in contemporary viewing, it is presented within the context of the era and, in the original review’s words, intended to be entertaining within that specific context.
For enthusiasts of the Western genre, “El Dorado” is not just recommended—it’s essential viewing. Even those who are not typically drawn to Westerns may find themselves thoroughly entertained and captivated by its compelling story, exceptional performances, and expertly crafted action. “El Dorado” stands as a testament to the enduring appeal of the Western and the timeless charisma of John Wayne.
9 of 10 stars.
The Hound.
