Long John Silver’s is a go-to for fast-food seafood cravings, offering a treasure trove of fish and seafood dishes. Beyond the familiar menu boards, however, lies a world of customizations and unofficial offerings known as the Long John Silver’s secret menu.
While not officially endorsed, this secret menu allows you to personalize your favorite meals and discover exciting new flavor combinations. To navigate this hidden culinary map, remember that availability can vary by location, and it’s always best to be prepared with specific instructions for the staff, rather than expecting them to know every secret menu item by name.
via Long John Silver’s
12 Exciting Items on the Long John Silver’s Secret Menu
Battered fish, grilled shrimp and battered shrimp
1. Spicy Wild Alaska Pollock Sandwich: Ignite Your Taste Buds
Elevate the classic Wild Alaska Pollock Sandwich, already recognized as a top contender among fast food fish sandwiches, with a fiery upgrade. The standard sandwich features crispy battered pollock, tangy pickles, and creamy tartar sauce. The secret menu twist? Swap out the tartar for a zesty Baja sauce, injecting a spicy kick that transforms the entire experience.
Beyond Baja sauce, explore other flavor profiles by requesting different sauces. Some locations might offer malt vinegar for a tangy tang, cocktail sauce for richness, or even classic ketchup, hot sauce, sweet honey mustard, or ranch for personalized flavor adventures.
2. Healthier Shrimp and Fish Tacos: Lighter and Fresher
Tacos are undeniably delicious, but sometimes the sauces and extras can add unwanted calories. For a lighter take, delve into the Long John Silver’s secret menu when ordering grilled shrimp or grilled salmon tacos. Request your tacos with less or no Baja sauce to significantly reduce the calorie count. For an even healthier approach, ask for an extra serving of vegetables to boost the nutritional value and freshness.
via Long John Silver’s
3. Surf and Turf Sliders: A Biscuit-Based Mashup
Long John Silver’s excels at both fish and chicken, and the secret menu unlocks a way to enjoy both in one bite, thanks to a clever hack involving biscuits. To create Surf and Turf Sliders, you’ll need to source biscuits separately – conveniently, many Long John Silver’s locations share space with KFC.
Order your choice of chicken and fish (either meals or individual pieces) from Long John Silver’s and grab biscuits from the KFC side. Assemble your sliders by placing battered fish and chicken inside the warm biscuits. Enhance your sliders with coleslaw or your favorite Long John Silver’s sauces. If biscuits aren’t available, a bun from Long John Silver’s can also work to create a Surf and Turf sandwich.
4. Fried Clams: A Crispy Coastal Treat (If You’re Lucky)
Fried clams are a highly coveted item on the Long John Silver’s secret menu. While they sometimes appear on the regular menu, availability is inconsistent, making them a delightful surprise when you can find them. These crispy, salty appetizers feature tender clam strips encased in a flavorful breaded coating, traditionally served with tartar sauce. For a spicy variation, request Baja sauce instead of tartar sauce.
Fried clams are a Long John Silver
5. Spicy Grilled Salmon Meal: Salmon with a Zing
Beyond fried fare, Long John Silver’s also shines with its grilled salmon meals. Amplify the flavor of this healthier option with a secret menu customization. Order the grilled salmon meal and ask for sweet chili or Baja sauce on the side. Drawing inspiration from the spicy sauces offered with salmon tacos and rice bowls, this request adds a tangy and spicy dimension to the grilled salmon, resulting in a balanced and flavorful meal.
6. Extra Crumblies: The Best Part of the Batter, Amplified
For true Long John Silver’s aficionados, the “crumblies” – those irresistible crispy fried batter bits – are a highlight. The secret menu unlocks the possibility of enjoying even more of these crunchy treasures. Simply ask for “extra crumblies” with your order. Staff are often happy to provide a side of these delightful morsels, perfect for dipping in your favorite sauce as an extra side treat.
via Long John Silver’s
7. Grilled Shrimp and Battered Chicken Platter: Customize Your Platter
Long John Silver’s platters are known for variety, and the secret menu allows for even greater personalization. Customize a platter by swapping out components to create your ideal combination. A popular secret menu hack is to order the shrimp and fish platter but replace the fish (salmon) with crispy battered chicken. For a slightly healthier twist, order a grilled shrimp meal or bowl and add a piece or two of battered chicken, balancing grilled and fried elements.
8. Free Chicken or Fish on “Talk Like a Pirate Day”: Ahoy, Matey! Free Grub!
This seasonal Long John Silver’s secret menu offer is a treasure worth marking on your calendar. Every September 19th, “Talk Like a Pirate Day,” you can plunder free food! Visit your local Long John Silver’s dressed in pirate attire and order your meal while speaking in your best pirate voice. Success earns you a free piece of fish or chicken to accompany your meal.
A basket with battered fish and chips
9. Crab Cake Sandwich: A Seafood Switch-Up
While the Wild Alaska Pollock Sandwich is a menu staple, swapping the filling opens up exciting possibilities. Request a crab cake instead of pollock for a unique sandwich experience. Pair it with the classic tartar sauce or venture into different flavors with Baja sauce or any other sauce that appeals to you. If your request isn’t directly accommodated, you can order both a fish sandwich and a crab cake and simply make the swap yourself.
10. Double Battered Fish: Extra Crunch, Extra Satisfaction
Craving maximum crispiness? The Long John Silver’s secret menu has you covered. Order your Alaska pollock, or any battered item, “double battered.” This simple request ensures your fish is dipped in batter twice before frying, resulting in an intensely crunchy texture that elevates the classic fried fish experience.
via Long John Silver’s
11. Cinnamon Sugar Hushpuppies: Sweeten the Deal
Hushpuppies are an essential part of the Long John Silver’s experience – those deep-fried, crispy cornmeal dough balls are hard to resist. For a dessert-like twist, tap into the secret menu and request cinnamon sugar hushpuppies. Ask for your hushpuppies to be lightly rolled in cinnamon sugar after frying. This simple addition transforms the savory side into a sweet treat, perfect for ending your seafood feast.
12. Loaded Bloody Mary: Seafood Brunch Cocktail (DIY)
This final Long John Silver’s secret menu item requires a bit of DIY spirit, but the result is a uniquely delicious brunch cocktail. Gather your desired Long John Silver’s add-ons – battered fish, popcorn shrimp, grilled spicy shrimp, hushpuppies – via takeout or delivery. Prepare a Bloody Mary at home and use your seafood selections as savory, unexpected garnishes.
A bloody mary cocktail with battered fish and shrimp garnish
The Long John Silver’s secret menu offers a world of flavorful possibilities beyond the standard menu. From spicy upgrades to customized platters and sweet hushpuppies, these hidden hacks provide exciting ways to enjoy your favorite seafood spot. So, next time you visit Long John Silver’s, don’t be afraid to explore the secret menu and discover your new favorite hidden gem!
