Pickles, a beloved side for many, have taken center stage in a quirky food innovation that’s captured the internet’s attention. For die-hard pickle enthusiasts, Jimmy John’s Picklewich presents a unique challenge to their devotion. This limited-time offering replaces the traditional sub bun with—you guessed it—a pickle, creating a sandwich that’s as unconventional as it is intriguing.
The Picklewich exploded onto social media, particularly TikTok, where countless users documented their first encounters and gave their verdicts on this pickled creation. Driven by curiosity and the online buzz, I ventured to try the Picklewich myself. Was it a stroke of genius, or just another fleeting internet sensation?
I opted for the turkey Picklewich, a seemingly straightforward choice featuring turkey, provolone cheese, lettuce, and tomato, all nestled between two substantial halves of a whole sliced pickle. Constructing a sandwich within a pickle is no easy feat, a culinary challenge I wouldn’t attempt at home. Credit to Jimmy John’s for the meticulous assembly. However, as anticipated, the Picklewich began to disassemble just a few bites in, proving that pickles might not be the most structurally sound sandwich vessel.
Despite the structural challenges, the taste was surprisingly harmonious. The Picklewich delivered a flavor profile reminiscent of a refreshing pickle salad, with a well-balanced blend of tastes. I admittedly approached this with some skepticism, expecting a textural and flavorless mess. Instead, I was pleasantly surprised by how well the pickle functioned as a “bun,” imparting a tangy and crisp element to each bite. One undeniable downside: the Picklewich was quite drippy, making for a less-than-elegant eating experience. Perhaps there’s a reason bread remains the standard for sandwiches!
Priced at $7.59, the Picklewich leans towards the smaller side and didn’t quite constitute a full meal. Yet, the price point feels somewhat justified by the novelty of the pickle bun and the overall buzz surrounding the product. You’re paying for an experience as much as a sandwich.
In conclusion, the Jimmy John’s Picklewich is a must-try for anyone who considers themselves a pickle aficionado. Available for a limited time until November 14th, it’s a quirky culinary adventure worth embarking on. However, it’s likely a one-time novelty rather than a new lunchtime staple. The Picklewich is the kind of fun food experiment you try once for the story and the experience, before returning to your regularly scheduled, more substantial meals. With the Picklewich, Jimmy John’s playfully demonstrates that sometimes, the most interesting path is the one that veers away from the expected—even if it means ditching the bread.
